%402x.svg)
In this episode, Craig Dowden reveals that the top use of AI is therapy and emotional support, highlighting a leadership vulnerability gap where many feel safer opening up to machines than people. He challenges leaders to create judgment-free spaces by listening with empathy and presence to foster deeper human connection and trust.
The Surprising Rise of AI as a Trusted Emotional Support and What It Means for Leadership Vulnerability
In today’s fast-paced, tech-driven world, it might come as a surprise that the top use of artificial intelligence isn’t about coding faster or boosting productivity. Instead, people are increasingly turning to AI for emotional support and therapy. Research by Harvard Business Review reveals that therapy and counseling rank as the number one reason individuals engage with AI, outranking even organizational or creative tasks. This shift highlights a deeper human need for connection, understanding, and a judgment-free space to explore feelings and challenges.
This trend raises a profound leadership challenge: why do people feel safer opening up to a machine than to another human? For leaders, especially senior executives, vulnerability in communication is often constrained by expectations of composure and decisiveness. The fear of judgment or appearing uncertain can make it difficult to express struggles openly. As AI models provide empathy without ego or defensiveness, they offer a revealing mirror to how leadership communication could evolve toward more openness and non-judgmental listening. Understanding this shift is key to creating environments where authentic human connection, and true leadership, can flourish.
The Leadership Vulnerability Gap: Why Senior Executives Struggle to Open Up
Leadership often comes with an invisible weight, one that presses leaders to always look confident, composed, and full of answers. Senior executives, in particular, face immense pressure to uphold a façade of decisiveness. Many believe, either consciously or not, that admitting uncertainty or struggle could undermine their authority. But this expectation creates a vulnerability gap that can take a serious toll on entire organizations.
The reality is, being at the top can be lonely. As you rise through the ranks, the number of people you can safely confide in shrinks.“The higher up you go, the fewer safe spaces you have to say, I don’t know, or I’m struggling, or I’m lost.” The expectation to project unwavering certainty means executives rarely get the chance to express doubt or admit when they’re overwhelmed. This forced composure may look strong on the outside, but it closes the door to authentic support and growth.
When leadership culture leaves no room for vulnerability, it impacts both mental health and team dynamics. Executives may carry the silent burden of stress, feeling like they can’t show weakness, even when they desperately need understanding or guidance. Over time, this stress compounds, often leading to isolation or burnout. Teams feel the ripple effect, too. When leaders never show vulnerability, it sends the message that others shouldn’t either. That stifles trust and discourages open, honest conversations across the board.
How to Close the Leadership Vulnerability Gap
- Acknowledge Your Own Vulnerability - Recognize that asking for support is a sign of strength, not weakness, and be honest about your own challenges.
- Create Safe Spaces for Dialogue - Establish regular, judgment-free forums where team members and leaders feel comfortable sharing doubts and struggles.
- Model Open Communication - Demonstrate vulnerability by sharing your own uncertainties or mistakes to encourage others to do the same.
- Practice Active, Non-Judgmental Listening - Focus fully on conversations without interrupting or rushing to solve, fostering trust and psychological safety.
- Encourage Reflective Silence - Allow pauses in dialogue so deeper insights can emerge instead of filling every silence with words.
- Use Curiosity Instead of Judgment - Respond to others’ frustrations with calm inquiry to validate feelings without escalating tension.
- Promote a Culture of Empathy and Support - Reinforce that vulnerability is valued and that seeking help is welcomed, leading to stronger relationships and team success.
Bringing Humanity Back: The Power of Empathy in Leadership
In a world where many people turn to machines for empathy, human connection remains the most powerful antidote. While AI can offer judgment-free listening and instant responses, it lacks the genuine warmth and understanding that only another human being can provide. Empathy, the ability to truly feel and understand another’s experience, is what builds bridges between people and fosters meaningful relationships. For leaders, bringing humanity back into conversations is essential to creating environments where individuals feel seen, heard, and valued.
Quote: "If your team, your colleagues, or your direct reports feel more comfortable being vulnerable with a chatbot than with you, what message does that send?" -Craig Dowden
One of the key techniques leaders can use to embody empathy is the “mirror, not magnify” approach. Instead of reacting strongly or amplifying someone’s frustration, leaders respond with calm curiosity. This means reflecting back what they hear with neutrality and openness, asking questions that invite deeper exploration rather than judgment.
The transformative effects of empathy in leadership ripple across trust, psychological safety, and team cohesion. When leaders consistently listen empathetically, trust naturally grows; people believe that their vulnerabilities won’t be weaponized or ignored. This trust lays the foundation for psychological safety, where team members feel secure enough to take risks, share innovative ideas, and admit mistakes. Over time, this openness strengthens team cohesion as members connect more authentically, collaborate more effectively, and support one another through challenges.
The Empathy Cycle in Leadership
Trust → Psychological Safety → Open Communication → Stronger Teams → Enhanced Performance
This cycle shows how empathy sparks a positive chain reaction that elevates both individual and organizational success. In essence, empathy is not just a “nice-to-have” soft skill but a strategic leadership tool. By bringing humanity back into conversations through empathetic listening and responses, leaders can unlock deeper engagement and create workplaces where everyone thrives.
Ready to take vulnerability and listening to the next level?
- To get practical tools and actionable tips that will jumpstart your journey, download the Vulnerability and Listening Kick Starter Booklet here.
- Join the newsletter to be notified when a new episode is ready for you to listen and get every Kick Starter Booklet for all future episodes.
- And if you’re looking to elevate your entire C-Suite leadership team, learn how Craig Dowden can help your leaders perform at their highest-level visit https://www.craigdowden.com/executive-mastermind
- For a deeper dive, listen to the full-length episode of the Do Good to Lead Well podcast featuring Wes Adams & Tamara Myles:
Did you like this article on the state of Ai therapy in organizations? Does it help you become a better leader? Then check out these articles to help hone those skills even further:
- Lead your team or company in the future with ethical AI practices: AI Driven Leadership Strategies for the Future with Geoff Woods
- Create an environment for Meaningful Work: Exploring the Science and Practice of Meaningful Work with Wes Adams and Tamara Myles
- Reveal and fill blindspots in your daily professional life: Seeing with New Eyes: Martin Dubin on Leadership, Self-Awareness, and Blindspotting
Craig Dowden
%401x.svg){kind=icon}
